« The Great Shake of 2011 | Main | David Brooks on moral individualism: The false dichotomy lives on »

September 1, 2011


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

If economic theories should be "judged by their internal logic", what is the value of these theories? Why do we need macroeconomic theories at all if the "evidence doesn't cut it"? And how do you prevent that the macroeconomic theories become nothing more than the economist's ideological preference articulated in an elaborate mathematical model? For if the evidence doesn't count, it becomes impossible to decide between the Keynesian approach and the free-market approach. If economy is all pragmatics, we can abandon macroeconomics, and replace it with a more pragmatic approach. (And I think this is not a bad idea at all, but I am only a humble philosopher of history.)

Thanks, Jeroen--theories are still useful insofar as they allow us to conceptualize how the economy works and what we should do with regard to it. In that sense, sure, theories are ideologies, but how can they not be--every economic theory starts with some basic axioms (even a pragmatic one), which inform the ultimate disagreement between the theories themselves.

In my mind, the debate over free markets versus statism (or Keynesianism) is primarily one of basic principles (both economic and ethical), and I think very fruitful discussion over their merits can be conducted at that level. (And the value of pragmatic considerations must be assessed the same way.)

Thank you for the (very quick) reply Mark, though I am sill not quite convinced of the usefulness of such theories besides heuristic devices. (Perhaps a bit like Kant's Principle of Purposiveness.)

We need a model to help conceptualize a problem and its possible solutions. At the same time, good old pragmatism is sometimes more effective than a bad model. That is, sometimes something turns out to work (by accident), even though it wasn't planned or intended. So keeping an open mind is critical--but unfortunately, many people do become professionally wedded to their pet theories. Hence the phrase, "Funeral by funeral, the discipline progresses...."

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Your Information

(Name is required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)

Accepting the Invisible Hand: Market-Based Approaches to Social-Economic Problems, Mark D. White (ed)

Beyond Social Capital: A Critical Approach, Irene van Stavern and Peter Knorringa (eds)

Economics and the Mind, Barbara Montero and Mark D. White (eds)

Ethics and Economics: New Perspectives, Mark D. White and Irene van Staveren (eds)

Ethics in Economics: An Introduction to Moral Frameworks, Jonathan B. Wight

The Feminist Economics of Trade, Irene van Staveren et al (eds)

Handbook of Economics and Ethics, Jan Peil and Irene van Staveren (eds)

The Illusion of Well-Being: Economic Policymaking Based on Respect and Responsiveness, Mark D. White

Kantian Ethics and Economics: Autonomy, Dignity, and Character, Mark D. White

Law and Social Economics: Essays in Ethical Values for Theory, Practice, and Policy, Mark D. White (ed.)

The Manipulation of Choice: Ethics and Libertarian Paternalism, Mark D. White

Retributivism: Essays on Theory and Policy, Mark D. White (ed.)

Saving Adam Smith: A Tale of Wealth, Transformation, and Virtue, Jonathan B. Wight

Street Porter and the Philosopher: Conversations on Analytical Egalitarianism, Sandra J. Peart and David M. Levy (eds)

Teaching the Ethical Foundations of Economics, Jonathan B. Wight and John S. Morton et al

Theoretical Foundations of Law and Economics, Mark D. White (ed.)

The Thief of Time: Philosophical Essays on Procrastination, Chrisoula Andreou and Mark D. White (eds)

The Values of Economics: An Aristotelian Perspective, Irene van Staveren

The Vanity of the Philosopher: From Equality to Hierarchy in Postclassical Economics, Sandra J. Peart and David M. Levy